OK it’s time for my results! I know you have all been anxious for these results because that sun is out and strong!!!! What an amazing weekend we had here in NY, I had many people contacting me asking what sunscreen to slap on their skin and I promised Tuesday so here it is!
Now let me preface this by saying I am not an expert, I’m just someone who enjoys doing hours of research on safe skin care and these are my results. You need to find products that work for you and you feel good about using.
Here is how the rating of the sunscreens work. I’ve gotten all of my data from http://www.ewg.org/skindeep/ and this is how their rating system works:
Sunscreen rating system — Summary
Our sunscreen rating system is based on a product-by-product analysis of safety and effectiveness. In our analysis of a product’s effectiveness we weigh four factors: UVA and UVB protection, balance, and the stability of active ingredient combinations. We combine these factors to derive a product effectiveness (sun hazard) rating. In our analysis of product safety we assess the potential for skin absorption and health hazards for all active ingredients (FDA-approved sunscreens) and all inactive ingredients to derive a product safety (health hazard) rating. We combine these two product ratings, effectiveness and safety, to derive an overall product rating using the following algorithm:

The sunscreen efficacy is calculated by taking 28% of the UVB protection + 28% of the UVA protection score + 28% of the UVA/UVB balance score + 16% of the sunscreen stability score. This is then combined with the health hazard score using at a variable ratio. For high hazard (health hazard score of 7 and higher), the efficacy score and health hazard score are combined at a 1:1 ratio. Using a linear regression, the efficacy score ratio is increased to 2:1 when the health hazard score reaches 0. This combined score is rounded to the nearest integer between 0 and 10.
We also flag sunscreen-specific hazards. Recent data suggest that sunscreens should not contain oxybenzone or vitamin A; not be aerosolized or powder; nor list SPF values over “50+”. Products with 1 of these hazards can not have a final score <3, products with 2 of more of these concerns cannot score better than 7. Powdered sunscreens cannot be scored better than 7 due to intense concerns about inhalation toxicity.
We include a score to account for UVA-UVB balance in sunscreens. There is growing awareness of ideal sunscreens offer reasonably similar protection across the UV spectrum. The growth of ultra high SPF sunscreens further exacerbates this problem, as UVA protection currently maxes out at about 20 in U.S. sunscreens (BASF 2011)
I’ll start with the bad. I had about 15 comments left by people telling me what sunscreen they use and wanting to know if it’s safe or not. First of all THANK YOU!!! Without your feedback I wouldn’t know where to begin!
Keep in mind when reading the results you really want to use a sunscreen that has a rating of 3 or lower, anything that rates a 5-10 in my opinion is way too toxic!

Here are those results in no particular order (bottom line-throw these out they are filled with toxic ingredients):
Coppertone Continuous Spray
Score: 7
UVB protection (SPF): Good
UVA protection: poor
Health concern: HIGH
Australian Gold Spray with bronzer (SPF 8)
Score: 7
UVB protection (SPF): moderate
UVA protection: poor
Health concern: HIGH
Overall hazar is HIGH
Cancer risk: low
Developmental * reporidtive toxicty: moderate
Allergies & immunotoxicity: high
Banana Boat Oil
Score: 7
UVB protection (SPF): moderate
UVA protection: moderate
Health concern: HIGH
Overall hazard is moderate to high
Cancer risk: low to moderate
Developmental * reporidtive toxicty: high
Allergies & immunotoxicity: moderate to high
Toxic Ingredients: Fragrance, Retinyl palimate, mineral oil
Neutrogena Mineral Sheers Powder Foundation, SPF 20
Score: 7
UVB protection (SPF): moderate
UVA protection: moderate
Health concern: HIGH
Overall hazard is high
Cancer risk: low to moderate
Developmental * reporidtive toxicty: high
Allergies & immunotoxicity: moderate
Toxic Ingredients:RETINYL PALMITATE (VITAMIN A PALMITATE), Alumina, Methylparaben, propylparaben
Jergens Natural Glow Daily Moisturizer, Designed for Medium Skin Tones
Score: 6
Health concern: moderate
Overall hazard moderate to high
Cancer risk: low
Developmental * reporidtive toxicty: low to moderate
Allergies & immunotoxicity: moderate to high
Toxic Ingredients: Fragrance, DMDM Hydantoin, methylparaben, propylparaben, BHT, mineral oil
Neutrogena Build-A-Tan for Faces Sunless Tanning, SPF 15
Score: 8
Health Concern: high
Overall Hazard: high
cancer: low
developmental and reproductive toxicity: low to moderate
Allergies and immunotoxicity: high
Toxic Ingredients: fragrance, oxybenzone, PEG-100 stearate, methylparaben, butylparaben, BHT, isbutylparaben, ispropylparaben
Hawaiian Tropic hawaiian tropic spf 45 plus sheer touch sunscreen
Score: 7
UVB protection (SPF): excellent
UVA protection: moderate
Health concern: HIGH
Overall hazard is moderate to high
Cancer risk: low to moderate
Developmental * reporidtive toxicty: very high
Allergies & immunotoxicity: high
Toxic Ingredients: fragrance, retinyl palmitate, oxybenzone, PEG’s, parabens
And a few others to stay away from that are popular:
- Neutrogena Baby Pure & Free Sunblock Lotion, Lotion, SPF 60+: Score: 7
- Neutrogena Healthy Defense Sunblock Lotion, Oil-Free, SPF 45: Score 7
- Neutrogena Ultra Sheer Body Mist Sunblock Lotion, SPF 70: Score 7

OK now for what you’ve been waiting for! The good stuff!!! Give your body what it deserves and apply one of these safe sunscreens this summer. Please remember reapply, reapply, reapply. You are not safe by just putting sunscreen on once for the day, just because it’s free of chemicals doesn’t mean it has super powers it needs to be reapplied as often as every half hour when you’re out baking in the sun.
My top 3 picks..in no particular order:
1. California Baby No Fragrance Sunscreen Lotion, SPF 30+
Score: 1
Price: $39.99
You can purchase here: http://www.californiababy.com/no-fragrance-spf-30-sunscreen-lotion-6-oz.htm
Here is the EWG report: http://breakingnews.ewg.org/2011sunscreen/about-the-sunscreens/323373/California_Baby_No_Fragrance_Sunscreen_Lotion%2C_SPF_30%2B/
Notes: Most of California Baby sunscreens are great, use these for you and your kids!
2. Badger Sunscreen, Lightly Scented Lavender, SPF 30+
Score: 1
Price: $16
Purchase here: http://www.badgerbalm.com/p-372-spf-30-for-face-body.aspx
Here is the EWG report: http://breakingnews.ewg.org/2011sunscreen/about-the-sunscreens/375118/Badger_Sunscreen%2C_Lightly_Scented_Lavender%2C_SPF_30%2B/
Notes: That little lavendar scent gives you a yummy smell if you don’t want to use unscented.
3. Aubrey Organics Natural Sun Unscented Sensitive Skin/Children Sunscreen, SPF 30+
Score: 1
Price: $14.99
Purchase here: http://www.allvitaminsplus.com/749985002639.html?utm_medium=shoppingengine&utm_source=googlebase&cvsfa=2348&cvsfe=2&cvsfhu=373439393835303032363339
Here is the EWG report: http://breakingnews.ewg.org/2011sunscreen/about-the-sunscreens/369501/Aubrey_Organics_Natural_Sun_Unscented_Sensitive_Skin%3B%3BChildren_Sunscreen%2C_SPF_30%2B/
For the kiddies:
Aveeno Baby Natural Protection Mineral Block Face Stick, SPF 50
Score: 1
Price: $8
Available at most stores
Here is the EWG report: http://breakingnews.ewg.org/2011sunscreen/about-the-sunscreens/388527/Aveeno_Baby_Natural_Protection_Mineral_Block_Face_Stick%2C_SPF_50/
Now my research is not complete, I have not tested these out in the sun myself yet. We all know how great things can look on paper but once you use a product sometimes it’s a different story. I have placed orders for all 3 sunscreens and will be testing them on myself out in the sun. Stay tuned for that entry later next month.
I’m not done with this topic, this is just the beginning, like I mentioned I will also be writing a post about makeup with SPF and lotions with SPF, etc. in the upcoming weeks.
Few closing notes:
*Coconut oil-that’s a new one and I’m going to do a little research and try it! I have heard about it blocking UV rays, worst comes to worse I’ll smell yummy!
*Jenna-you’re Neutrogena Light Sesame Oil is not as great as it seems! Dump it!
*Not all natural sunscreens are SAFE…be sure to do your research. Some of them have ratings as high as 9 or 10!!
For those of you that want to do some research yourself or just want some reading material…
*Best sunscreens
*Sunscreen hall of shame
*Sunscreens exposed
To be continued…
